Ελληνικά

Ethereum: Peraire-Bueno brothers acquitted in $25 million case

When does exploiting a flaw in code amount to fraud, and what must prosecutors prove?

2 - 3'
A judge's gavel above a glowing Ethereum symbol, illustrating the acquittal in the MEV case.
Ethereum (ETH) today €1,562 +2.0% in 24h Price and chart

Anton and James Peraire-Bueno were acquitted on November 16, 2026, of the remaining charges in a case involving approximately $25 million in Ethereum transactions. US District Judge Jessica G. L. Clarke in Manhattan ruled that prosecutors had not proved a material misrepresentation, an essential element of the specific wire fraud charge.

Why were the Peraire-Bueno brothers acquitted?

The central gap in the prosecution's case was its failure to identify what material misrepresentation the two brothers had made in their transactions. According to coverage by Unchained and The Block, Clarke granted the motion for acquittal, bringing the case to a close.

The charge of conspiracy to commit that fraud also fell, along with the money laundering charge, which depended on proving the fraud. The judge distinguished the legal question from whether the conduct was right, ethical, or potentially in violation of other laws not included in the indictment.

This was not a case that ended at its first hearing. The charges were filed in May 2024. In November 2025, after a trial lasting nearly four weeks and three days of deliberations, the jury was unable to reach a verdict.

How are MEV and the $25 million connected?

The case concerned maximal extractable value (MEV), the profit that can be generated by selecting and ordering transactions within a block. Think of a line where your position changes the financial outcome: someone can profit because their transaction executes before or after yours.

According to prosecutors, in April 2023 the brothers placed bait transactions to attract automated trading programs, or trading bots, that carry out sandwich attacks. These bots place transactions before and after another user's order in an attempt to profit.

The bots responded with private transaction bundles, intended to execute together and in a specific order. Prosecutors alleged that the brothers exploited a bug in the code of an intermediary relay, viewed the bundles, and replaced the bait transactions with transactions of their own. The bots lost approximately $25 million in about 12 seconds.

This infrastructure used MEV-Boost, open-source software from Flashbots for validators, the computers that propose and confirm new blocks. Flashbots patched the relay code within 24 hours.

Does the ruling make MEV attacks legal?

The acquittal does not make MEV attacks broadly legal or endorse every exploitation of a flaw in code. It concerns the specific charges and what was proved at trial.

Clarke also rejected the comparison to placing orders that a trader intends to cancel, known as spoofing. She noted that the bait transactions were published on the blockchain within about a minute and that this particular environment lacked the rules of an organized, regulated market that would prohibit the conduct in question. Efforts to conceal identity could also be relevant to intent, but could not substitute for proof of a false statement.

What does this mean for Ethereum users?

The technical risk of MEV remains, regardless of the outcome of the criminal case. If you are a user in Greece transacting directly on Ethereum, the order of execution can still affect the price you ultimately receive.

Better transaction routing, limits on acceptable price slippage, and protocol improvements can reduce some forms of exploitation, but cannot eliminate competition for priority. We consider the distinction essential: proving criminal fraud is one thing; ensuring safe transaction execution is another. The ruling clarifies the former in this particular case without resolving the latter.

Rate us!

Your rating and feedback are valuable to help us improve your experience on our website.

(0 votes)