Polymarket: Prediction or gambling by another name?
If you pay to predict who will win, how is that different from a bet?

Polymarket is both a forecasting mechanism and a place where you can lose money betting on uncertain events. As of November 17, 2026, sports have overtaken politics in trading volume, while US courts have yet to settle whether its contracts fall exclusively under federal derivatives oversight or are also subject to state gambling rules.
How does Polymarket work?
Polymarket lets you buy and sell contracts on the outcomes of events. In a typical binary market, “Yes” costs between zero and one dollar and pays one dollar if that outcome occurs; otherwise, it pays nothing. “No” pays out on the opposite outcome. You can also sell before final settlement.
Buying “Yes” at 60 cents? If you are right, your gross profit is 40 cents. If not, you lose the 60 cents. Fees and execution costs reduce returns: the international platform charges fees on some trades, but not all, while the US platform has a separate fee schedule.
Buyers and sellers set the price, rather than a traditional bookmaker. A price of 60 cents is interpreted as a 60% probability, not as a poll in which 60% of people agree. What matters is money, information, willingness to take risks, and liquidity—how easily you can find counterparties.
How did it go from a fine to Wall Street?
Polymarket's history includes regulatory penalties, election-driven attention, and major investments, but it now involves two separate operations.
- 2020 Shayne Coplan founds Polymarket. The US Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) later placed the start of its unregistered operations at around June.
- January 3, 2022 The CFTC imposes a $1.4 million fine and orders noncompliant markets to shut down, classifying the contracts in question as swaps. It acknowledges the company's cooperation.
- 2024 The international market for the winner of the US election draws roughly $3.6 billion in trading volume. Donald Trump, who had been the favorite, wins.
- July 21, 2025 The acquisition of QCEX for $112 million is announced, including a licensed exchange and clearinghouse. Polymarket US launches late in the year.
- October 2025 and March 27, 2026 Intercontinental Exchange, the owner of the New York Stock Exchange, invests $1 billion and announces an additional direct investment of $600 million, respectively.
- October 27, 2026 Reuters reports a new CFTC investigation into the exclusion of Americans from the international platform. An earlier investigation had closed without charges; the new one is not a finding of wrongdoing.
Polymarket US operates through CFTC-registered QCX LLC. The international crypto platform does not have that registration and says it excludes Americans. We should not automatically apply findings about one to the other. Nor should we label investments or trading volume as “revenue.”
How reliable are its predictions?
Markets can aggregate useful information without becoming oracles. Different sources of knowledge converge in a single price that changes with the news. The Council on Foreign Relations also describes the use of election markets for hedging—limiting potential business losses from political changes.
Rajiv Sethi, Julie Seager, and colleagues compared Polymarket with three statistical forecasts for the 2024 US election. In their test, the models did not outperform the main presidential market, but some performed better in lower-profile races. They also found susceptibility to volatility and manipulation.
In Brazil, Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva won the runoff on October 25, 2026, even though markets had given him roughly a 20% chance. That alone does not prove a failure: a well-calibrated 20% probability should materialize in roughly one out of five comparable cases. Similarly, one successful call on Trump does not prove lasting superiority.
Why does the gambling comparison persist?
For participants, the risk looks much like betting: money placed on an uncertain outcome, with the possibility of a loss. Calling it a “contract” does not change that experience.
According to the Pew Research Center, sports were the largest category on both Polymarket and rival Kalshi. In June and July 2026, a period that coincided with the World Cup, sports trading volume approached $22 billion on Polymarket, including its US platform. Politics averaged roughly $2 billion in monthly volume from the beginning of the year through the study period. The US operation reached 39% of total volume in July, up from 4% in January.
In a separate sample of 11,989 active international wallets, from May 7 to June 19, 2026, the median was 46 trades. Nine percent lost more than $1,000, while 7% gained more than that amount. Among wallets with at least 1,000 trades, the figures were 33% and 27%. The sample covered high-volume events, excluded Polymarket US, and did not necessarily represent unique individuals.
Who controls the information and the outcome?
A market's quality depends both on unequal access to information and on who decides what happened. The “wisdom of the crowd” can include a handful of players with very deep pockets.
Before the 2024 election, Polymarket identified a major bettor backing Trump as a French trader with a financial background. Chainalysis estimated profits of more than $85 million for potentially linked accounts. The links and the amount were estimates, not proof of manipulation.
On April 23, 2026, US prosecutors charged service member Gannon Ken Van Dyke with using classified information about the operation to capture Nicolás Maduro: roughly $33,034 in bets and $409,881 in profit. He pleaded not guilty and sought dismissal of the case; there has been no conviction. Similarly, successful bets ahead of the US-Israeli strikes in February 2026 prompted calls for investigations, not proof of guilt.
On the international platform, disputes have gone through UMA's verification mechanism, or oracle, where token holders vote. In 2025, even the question of whether Volodymyr Zelenskyy wore a “suit” became a dispute over interpretation and concentrated voting power. WIRED also reported an earlier instance in which Polymarket overturned a UMA outcome.
What is the legal situation in the US and Greece?
Federal registration has not resolved the conflict with gambling rules. On September 24, 2026, Attorney General Letitia James and Governor Kathy Hochul filed suit against Polymarket US over allegedly unlicensed activity, seeking a halt to operations, refunds, and penalties.
New York cites access for people ages 18–20, rather than the minimum age of 21 for mobile sports betting, as well as the bypassing of licensing and taxes. These are disputed allegations. The platforms argue that federal jurisdiction takes precedence, while states and tribal gaming operators disagree. Court rulings have diverged.
Under Michael Selig, the CFTC withdrew a proposal to restrict election contracts and backed the companies in court. Donald Trump Jr.'s investment through 1789 Capital, dating from 2025, also raises political questions. On November 12, 2026, Kalshi confirmed the end of his paid advisory role, citing his increased investment in its competitor. Both companies deny receiving favorable treatment because of family ties.
As for Greece, the French regulator ANJ said in February 2026 that it was among the countries that had blocked Polymarket for lacking the required license. ANJ itself had secured geoblocking in France. The precise state of enforcement in Greece today requires separate confirmation; this should not be generalized to all prediction markets.
Our view
We believe Polymarket can produce useful forecasts while also being used for gambling. Some people hedge risk, some have fun, and some chase their losses. A useful price does not eliminate the potential for harm.
We would take a more positive view with repeated evidence of accuracy, transparent settlements, and effective participant protections. Documented manipulation or exploitation of privileged information would make us more cautious. Until then, the “prediction” label is not enough to take gambling out of the equation.
